Management Of Deaf And Mute Completely Edentulous Patient Using Various Communication Aids During Complete Denture Rehabilitation- A Review And A Case Report
Radhika Krishnan C1, Anupama Aradya2*, Raghavendra Swamy K N3
1 Post Graduate Student, Department of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, JSS Dental College and Hospital, Mysuru, Karnataka, India.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, JSS Dental College and Hospital, Mysuru, Karnataka, India.
3 Professor and Head of the Department, Department of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, JSS Dental College and Hospital, Mysuru, Karnataka, India.
*Corresponding Author
Anupama Aradya,
Assistant Professor, Department of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, JSS Dental College and Hospital, Mysuru, Karnataka, India.
Tel: 9379463612
E-mail: dranupamavenu@gmail.com
Received: August 08, 2021; Accepted: September 28, 2021; Published: October 04, 2021
Citation:Radhika Krishnan C, Anupama Aradya, Raghavendra Swamy K N. Management Of Deaf And Mute Completely Edentulous Patient Using Various Communication Aids
During Complete Denture Rehabilitation- A Review And A Case Report. Int J Dentistry Oral Sci. 2021;8(10):4734-4742. doi: dx.doi.org/10.19070/2377-8075-21000962
Copyright: Anupama Aradya©2021. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Abstract
Background: Hearing impairment is a condition in which patients are fully/ partially unable to detect some frequencies of
sound that are perceived by normal individuals. It can be congenital/acquired, conductive/sensorineural (with associated
speech impairement)/mixed; unilateral/bilateral, and mild/moderate/severe/profound.
Management of a deaf and mute completely edentulous individual is always challenging. Hence, a prosthodontist needs to be
sensitive to the non-verbal mode of communication.
Case Report: A 57-year-old female patient reported with a chief complaint of missing upper and lower teeth and inability to
chew. She is suffering from hearing loss and difficulty in speaking due to childhood trauma. Medical records revealed sensorineural
bilateral severe hearing loss (80 dB) and speech impairment.
Intraoral examination showed completely edentulous maxillary and mandibular arches.
The rehabilitation with conventional complete denture was madesuccessful by establishing an effective communication with
patient and reciprocation of the functional movements by the patients, upon using combination of 4 different modes of
communications like sign languages, visual aids –models, videos, lip-reading by the patient and by the guidance of interpreter/
bystander.
Conclusion: The challenge of communicating with deaf and mute during treatment phase of complete denture could be
overcome by using combinations of communication modes rather than relying on a single mode. Visual aids and sign language
gave better responses than other modes.
2.Introduction
3.Materials and Methods
3.Results
4.Discussion
5.Conclusion
5.References
Introduction
Hearing impairment is “ a condition in which patients are fully or
partially unable to detect some frequencies of sound that are perceived
by normal individuals”. As per the WHO report 2021, 466
million individuals are suffering from hearing impairment problems
(includes 34 million children and 432 million adults) and estimated
that by 2050, over 700 million people, i.e. 1 in every 10
individuals will have disabling hearing loss.[1] Hearing loss is also
accompanied by speech impairment. Such impairment caused by
trauma/head injury/loud noises/inherited genetically/aging process
results in sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) resulting from
damage to the structures in the inner ear/auditory nerve/auditory
pathway. 90 % of the hearing loss in adults is SNHL and considered
as the most common type of hearing loss.[1] Even though
the hearing loss and speech disability is not fatal, it has a negative
impact on patients’ life, creating a social stigma which in turn affects
mental health.
Prosthodontic management of a deaf and mute completely edentulous
individual is always challenging especially to execute the
various functional movements by patients with tongue, jaws, and
oral musculature during impression making, jaw relation, trial insertion,
and denture insertion. Hence, a prosthodontist should be
sensitive to the nonverbal mode of communication such as facial
expressions, sign languages, postural movements, visual aids,
etc. as a mode of conveying the information during the treatment
phase and for post-insertion care.
This article gives information about the hearing loss and speech
impairement along with its treatment recommendation and communication
mode to be adopted during the treatment through a
review and case report that describes the use of combination of
non-verbal communication aids like sign language, expression,
visual aids, models, and guidance by the bystander (lip reading)
to rehabilitate the completely edentulous deaf and mute patient
(sensorineural hearing loss and speech impairement) with a conventional
complete denture successfully.
Hearing Loss And Deafness
• A person is said to have hearing loss when they are unable to
hear particular frequencies of sound that are perceived by a normal
individual
• Normal hearing indicates hearing thresholds of 20 dB or better
in both ears.
• Disabling hearing loss is a condition in which hearing loss is
above 35dB in the better ear.
• Hard of hearing refers to those with hearing loss ranging from
mild to severe. They can use spoken language for communication.
They also benefit from hearing aids, cochlear implants, and other
assistive devices & captioning.
• ‘Deaf ’individual has profound hearing loss, indicates very little
or no hearing. Use sign language for communication.[1]
Types Of Hearing Loss: [2]
They are of mainly 4 types:
• Conductive Hearing Loss: Resulting from something that prevents
sounds from passing through the outer or middle ear. Often
treated by medicine or surgery.
• Sensorineural Hearing Loss: Results due to damage in the inner
ear or auditory nerve or auditory pathway.
• Mixed Hearing Loss: Combination of both the conductive and
the sensorineural hearing loss.
• Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder:The condition in
which the sound enters the ear normally, but, the sound is not
organized in a way that the brain can understand due to damage
to the inner ear or the hearing nerve.
Hearing loss can also be:
1. Unilateral/Bilateral: Hearing loss occurs in one / both the ear
respectively.
2. Pre-lingual/ Post-lingual: Hearing loss that occurs before/ after
a person learn to talk respectively.
3. Symmetrical/Asymmetrical: Hearing loss is similar in both
ears/varies in each ear respectively.
4. Progressive/Sudden: Hearing loss that worsens over a period
time/happens quickly respectively.
5. Fluctuating/Stable: Hearing loss that gets either better or worse
over time/stays the same over time respectively.
6. Congenital/Acquiredor delayed onset:Hearing loss is present at
birth/appears sometime later in life respectively.
Etiology Of Hearing Impairment: [1, 2]
Conductive hearing loss: The following can cause conductive hearing loss.
• earwax
• hole/defect in the tympanic membrane
• benign tumors
• obstruction by foreign objects
• deformations in the outer or middle ear
• blockade of Eustachian tube due to common cold
Sensorineural hearing loss: Damage to the hair cells/neural pathway
results from:
• hereditary
• injury to 8th cranial nerve
• infections
• head injury/trauma
• autoimmune disease
• Meniere’s disease
• certain drugs or medications- streptomycin
• vascular/circulation problem
• loud noise (>80 dB)
Classification For Hearing Impairment
Goodman classification (1965). (Table 1). [3].
WHO’s first classification of hearing impairment was put forth in
1986, modified to current version (published in 1991) (Table 2).[4]
GBD Expert Group revisited the WHO classification and proposed
new classification systems in 2010 with inclusion of certain
changes (Table 3). [4]
Role Of Audition In Voice/ Speech Production [5,6]
• Voice/ speech is produced by the integration of the respiratory,
phonatory, articulatory, resonatory, nervous system,, and by the
6th component audition according to Lawson et al.
• Audition – The mechanism involves reception and interpretation
of speech. Audition not only permits oral communication
but also enables the individual to check, guide and control own
speech output.
? Provides information about voice targets, for correction of
pitch, volume, and other attributes to create an intelligible speech.
? Provides feedback about environmental conditions, which is
vital in noisy situations, so that the speaker knows to enunciate
more clearly, to increase amplitude, and to slow down the speaking
rate to improve intelligibility.
The auditory system two types of control over speech production.
1. Feedback control – Monitor the performance of task during
execution and deviation from desired performance, which are
corrected in accordance with sensory information
2. Feedforward control –In this task is executed using previously
learned commands, without relying on incoming task-related sensory
information.
Auditory feedback influences both feedforward and feedback control mechanisms in speech and voice production.[6]
Speech hence produced are of two types
Spoken speech: [5-9]
Spoken speech means understanding spoken word and expressing
the ideas in speech
Mechanism:
Sound is heard( require an intact auditory pathway from ear to
Figure 1. Visual aid for patient education.
Figure 2. Instructions to deaf and mute patient using sign languages during complete denture fabrication.
Figure 3. Interpreter (bystander) aiding in lip-reading of words like ‘emma’, ‘om’, ‘m’ for recording vertical dimension at
rest.
Figure 4. Steps in complete denture fabrication and complete denture models used to give post-insertion instructions.
primary auditory centre (area 41)
Sound must be able to understand ( require an active auditory
psychic area- area 20, 21)
Interpretation and understanding of auditory and visual informations
by Wernicke’s area-(area 22)
Broca’s speech area (area 44) process the information received
into a detailed and coordinated pattern of vocalization.
Pattern is projected into motor cortex, which initiates appropriate
movement of lip, tongue, and larynx to produce speech.
Written speech: [5-9]
Written speech means understanding written words and expressing
the ideas in writing.
Mechanism:
1. Viewing the word (requires intact visual pathway, area- 17)
2. written symbols are interpreted (visuopsychic area- area18, 19)
3. express ideas in writing (Dejerine’s area – area 39)
4. converted to auditory form (Wernickes area- area 22)
Speech Disorder
A speech disorder is a condition in which a person has problems
creating or forming the speech sounds or quality of voice needed
to communicate with others.
Classified mainly as 3 types:
SOUND DISORDER: Due to motor/neurological disorder (
traumatic brain injury, stroke), structural abnormalities (cleft lip
and palate/after surgery of neoplasm), sensory/perceptual disorder(
hearing impairement leading to speech sound difficulties,
unable to hear the sound the way they produce them).
FLUENCY DISORDER: Associated with difficulties in rhythm
and timing of speech characterized by hesitations, repetitions, or
prolongations of sounds, syllables, words, or phrases. Eg: stuttering
, cluttering.
VOICE DISORDER: It can be structural (vocal fold edema,
nodules)/neurogenic (vocal tremor, paralysis of vocal fold caused
by problems nervous system innervation to larynx).[10]
The presented case in this article is categorized based on above
classification system of hearing impairement and speech disorder
as severe sensorineural hearing loss (according to WHO 1991 and
Goodman 1965) which is bilateral, pre-lingual, symmetrical, sudden
and stable type with sensory speech sound disorder and spoken
speech impairement. (The patient here is capable for written
speech, the patient writes her name and signature but not other
words as she is illiterate).
General Management Of A Deaf And Mute Individuals
Patients with hearing loss and speech impairement should be investigated
and should undergo a full audiometric evaluation by a
multidisciplinary team, including an otolaryngologist, audiologist,
radiologist and speech/language therapist as early as possible.
Early Intervention (0-3 years)
Babies diagnosed with hearing loss should get intervention as
soon as possible not later than 6 months of age because hearing
loss can affect a child’s ability to develop speech, language, and
social skills.[11, 12] This include:
7:1:1 Hearing aids:
Hearing aids make sounds louder. They can be worn by people of
any age, including infants (0-6 months).[11]
Cochlear and Auditory Brainstem Implants
A cochlear implant may help many children (even infants less than
12 months) and adult with severe to profound hearing loss. Unlike
conventional hearing aid, cochlear implants do not amplify
sound , instead they bypass the damaged part of auditory system
and directly stimulate auditory nerve. They sends sound signals
directly to the hearing nerve. Hearing aid and cochlear implant
won’t benefit individuals with severe to profound hearing loss due
to an absent or very small hearing nerve or severely abnormal
inner ear (cochlea), instead an auditory brainstem serves the role.
This directly stimulates the hearing pathways in the brainstem,
bypassing the inner ear and auditory nerve.
Both these implants have two main component- The inner component
placed inside the inner ear, the cochlea, or base of the
brain, the brainstem during surgery, and the outer component
worn outside the ear after surgery. The outer component sends
sounds to the inner component. These aids are used in sensorineural
hearing loss. [11]
Bone anchored hearing aids
Used in children (even in 2- 4yrs)/adult with conductive or mixed
or unilateral hearing loss (malformed outer/middle ear) and requires
a functional inner ear. Specifically for children who cannot
wear hearing aids ‘in the ear’ or ‘behind the ear’. Here implants
placed surgically in bone behind the ear and conduct the sound
wave through the bone to inner ear. [11]
Special Education (3-22 years)
Instructions are specifically designed to address the educational
and related developmental needs of older children with disabilities,
or those who are experiencing developmental delays. Should
begin as soon as hearing loss is diagnosed or 2- 5 years of age
which ever is the first. At these age most of the speech development
occurs.
Consult a speech therapist who build the communication by various activities:
1. Help in developing proper grammar and sentences.
2. Exercises that helps strengthen and learn how to move your
lips, mouth, and tongue to make certain sounds and also to allow
swallowing if any difficulty exists in doing so.
3. Helps in learning various communication methods, such as:
o sign language
o finger spelling
o writing
o gestures
o facial expressions
o assistive technology
These skills along with hearing aids, cochlear or auditory brainstem
implants, and other devices help a deaf and mute individual
to hear and reciprocate to the commands and communicate.[11]
Other Assistive Devices
FM System
Helps the individual with hearing loss to hear in background noise.
The frequency modulation signal system is the same as that of a
radio system. Used along with hearing aids. An extra component
is attached to the hearing aid that works with the FM system.[11]
Captioning
The conversation spoken is shown as sound track of a program
on the bottom of the television screen as in television programs,
videos, and DVDs. [11]
Text messaging
Telephone amplifiers
Flashing and vibrating alarms
Audio loop systems
Infrared listening devices
Portable sound amplifiers
TTY (Text Telephone or teletypewriter).[14]
Medical and Surgical intervention
Benefits individuals with conductive hearing loss, or one that involves
a part of the outer or middle ear.
Conductive hearing loss due to chronic ear infection is treated
with medication (antibiotics , anti- inflammatory drugs) and careful
monitoring. Infections that persist even after using medication
can be treated with a simple surgery by inserting a tiny tube into
the eardrum to drain the fluid out.
Conductive hearing loss due to malformation of the outer and or
middle ear and can be treated by surgical placement of cochlear
implant, auditory brainstem implant, or bone-anchored hearing
aid, and sensorineural hearing loss by cochlear and auditory brainstem
implants. [11]
Communication Modes Used For Treating A Deaf And Mute Patient
This includes:
Speech reading/ lip reading
Hearing impaired individuals are good speech readers. The practitioner
or interpreter should speak facing the patient in normal
pace with clear and good articulation, thence, allowing the reading
of the lips. The medical terms should be conveyed in their
language or English whichever is best known to them. It may vary
with individual of same hearing loss based on their knowledge in
Standard English or their own language. Hence, this alone cannot
be considered as a means of communication instead a combination
of speechreading and amplification enables to combine the
auditory and visual cues successfully to carry out a conversation.
[13]
Wrting
The first opted communication alternative by a physician when
the normal conversation is impaired. It can be used to communicate
with hearing-impaired patients, along with speech reading
with understandable or partly understandable patient speech.
Writing alone can’t be used a conversational mode as it is slow,
frustrating and ponderous to use.
The response varies with patient's knowledge as well as with understanding
of standard English / own language. An individual
with pre-lingual hearing loss and who is illiterate, it is quite difficult
to follow the instructions written and may require an interpreter
to convey them.[13]
Visual Aids
A picture is always worth than a thousand words. Visual aids can
be a chart, diagram or picture, videos, models that can be used to
illustrate medical terminology or processes. This is advantageous
to physician, deaf and mute patients and interpreter.
Tips to use visual aids:
1. Should be positioned vertical and close to patient without
blocking by practioner’s face . Hence patient can view both the
aid and practitioner at a time, thereby avoiding constant shift of
visual focus.
2. Practice working with a visual aid from behind so that practitioner
can point things out without changing the practitioner’s
posture and position of aids constantly.
3. Do not talk/ point intricacies in between while using visual aid
as the patient can look only one thing at a time.[13]
Visual Language
There are various forms of visual language used by hearing impaired
individuals. The use of same type of visual language that
have been using outside would be preferred by most of the patient
for better understanding and reciprocation of the commands
given by practitioner procedure. This includes some combination
of the following:
Finger Spelling Each letter of the alphabet expressed by hand configuration,
but this is difficult to understand for an untrained individual and
slower than the spoken communication. However, any physician
who can finger spell and read finger spelling-even badly-tremendously
facilitates his relationship with deaf patients. As with any
linguistic group, someone who is trying to communicate in their
language means a great deal to the hearing-impaired person. By
doing so patients feels that such a physician is more likely to accept
and cares them and in turn, they will accept and trust the
physician.[13]
Signs
Vocabulary and concepts in general situations and in medical or
dental practices ,are expressed by a system of sign language alleviating
the need to use finger spelling for and making rapid conversation
.These basic sign along with facial expression, or with
variation in the way the sign is produced made the conversation
fruitful with better understanding.[13]
Manual or signed English
This mode of language is taught in schools for deaf and mute
individuals where standard English is taught. Here sign is drawn
from Ameslan (American Sign language) and finger spelling are
integrated with the grammatical structure of standard English.
This creates a bridge between visual language and standard English
and lead to development of bilingual persons who can potentially
operate well in both a standard English dominated society
and in the hearing-impaired community. These "anglicized
“forms of sign language are slower and more tedious to use.[13]
The Interpreter-Role and Function
An interpreter's role is to act as a mediator in between the two primary
participants, thereby transmitting the information precisely
and rapidly from the hearing-impaired to the hearing and back
again in two basic situations:
* When communication between one person to other is impossible.
* When the an important information like explain procedure and
consent for a major surgical operation or due to time constraints
slow or occasionally inaccurate communication cannot be preferred.[
13]
Tips On The Use Of An Interpreter:
1. Try to choose an interpreter certified by the National Registry
of Interpreters for the Deaf.
2. Seat the interpreter as close as possible to you so that the patient
avoids the "ping-pong" effect (excessive movement of the
eyes between you and the interpreter).
3. Practitioner can monitor interpreter through side vision rather
than interfering in between communication. This allows you to
develop the ability to tell how well the interpreter is keeping up
with you and thereby to pause when he or she falls behind. In
regard to your role, always talk directly to the patient and avoid
talking about a patient in the third person.[13]
Prosthodontic Considerations
Case presentation
A 57 year old philosophical female patient reported to the Department
of Prosthodontics and Crown & Bridge, JSSDC & H,
Mysuru, with the chief complaint of missing upper and lower
teeth and inability to chew. Patient had undergone extraction
of teeth due to looseness in a sequence of mandibular anterior
teeth first followed by maxillary anterior teeth, mandibular posterior
teeth and mandibular posterior teeth. Past medical history
revealed patient has rheumatoid arthritis since past 6 years and
was under medication for the same. Also patient is suffering from
hearing loss and difficulty in speaking since past 53 years. Medical
reports revealed bilateral severe sensorineural hearing loss and
speech impairment (hearing loss of 80 dB HL in both the ears)
(according to classification by Goodman in 1965, WHO 1991) (
Table 1 , Table 2). Considered as profound hearing loss category
according to GBD Expert Group 2010 (Table 3). Patient had a
history of fall and head injury during childhood at the age of 4
following which she lost the hearing and speech ability. She consulted
an ENT specialist and started using hearing aid at the age
of 25. Even though it was helpful in hearing , she discontinued
the use of same after 11/2 year as it is a body wrap type and larger
in size which led to discomfort in wearing the same. Further she
adapted to the situation and started lip reading and communication
via sign languages and facial expression. She also experienced
difficulty in reciprocating the words spoken by a stranger even in
loud tone, at the same time she found it easy to understand and
reciprocate back among her daughter and family members.
Intraoral examination revealed completely edentulous high well
rounded maxillary and mandibular arch, with squarish and U
shaped arch form respectively. Unilateral maxillary anterior undercut
(right labial aspect) present.
In this case, the management of patient mainly focused on utilization
of 4 different modes of communication for hearing and
speech impaired individual during fabrication of conventional
complete denture like:
1. Visual aids- Include videos and models (Figure 1 & 4 respectively)
2. Sign language- Different signs were used individually for conveying
different functional movements prior to procedure in-office.
( Figure 2)
3. Bystander as an interpreter as the patient is illiterate to convey
the information to and from the practitioner and patient.( Figure
3)
4. Lip reading technique – For carrying out the procedure requiring
phonetics like jaw relation etc.( Figure 3)
Prosthodontic management of the presented edentulous
deaf and mute patient
The treatment plan was fabrication of conventional complete
denture as patient was not ready for any invasive procedure like
implant supported denture.
All through the appointments patient was accompanied by her
daughter (acted as an interpreter/ translator) due to the difficulty
in hearing and speech. Patient education about the treatment was
well explained with the help visual aid- video (Figure 1), case history
and other relevant information regarding the patient were collected from patient with the help of by stander during the first
appointment. The consent for treatment and taking photographs
was obtained from the patient and her daughter as well.
The medical reports from All India Institute of Speech and Hearing
, Mysuru described that the patient has bilateral severe sensorineural
hearing loss and speech impairment ( hearing loss of 80
dB HL in both the ears) since 4 years of age due to alleged history
of fall.
Two days before each appointment videos related to the treatment
(impression making, maxillomandibular relations, try in and
post insertion procedures) were send to the patients’ daughter via
smartphone for better understanding of the procedure by the patient,
to practice the required tongue/oral musculature and jaw
movements and there by reducing the anxiety and fear to the procedure.
In the second appointment primary impressions (DPI Pinnacle
Impression compound) (Figure 4a, 4b) were made followed by
fabrication of a primary cast on to which a special tray was fabricated
with self-cure acrylic resin( DPI RR Cold cure acrylic) ,
border molding ( DPI Pinnacle tracing stick) was done and final
impressions( DPI Impression Paste- ZOE) (Figure 4c, 4d) were
made and a master cast(Type III-Kalstone) was fabricated. These
procedures were made successful by using visual aids like videos
played in laptop and asking the patient to reciprocate the same.
Also a synergistic effect in patients ‘response was seen when sign
languages and the guidance by the bystander/ interpreter to evoke
same movements (as in cases of Valsalva maneuver etc. ) was used
along with the visual aid (Figure 2a to 2m).
During the second appointment itself patient was educated
about the next procedure along with videos ; and the patient was
guided accordingly. Related videos were sent to patients daughter
for practicing the movements. Hence, the third appointment
for recording jaw relation was made easier. Record bases (Shellac
base plate- MAARC) and rims (Hindustan Modelling Wax- No.
2)were constructed conventionally for jaw relations. Patient was
positioned upright and occlusal rims were inserted and checked
for lip support, visibility – at rest , high lip line low lip line by
using sign language- smile ( Figure 2n) along with guidance by
the bystander through facial expression. Followed by recording
orientation jaw relation, vertical jaw relation at rest by seating patient
in relaxed position and phonetic method , here interpreter
reciprocate the word spelled by practitioner which is then read
( lip reading) by the patient-”m, Emma, Om” (Figure 3, 4f); and
vertical dimension at occlusion by sign language asking patient
to swallow and occlude and facial measurements recorded and
obtained the freeway space( Figure 2o, 2p, 4e). Phonetic methods
(f, v, s-) were used to evaluate closest speaking space with the help
of interpreter as previously mentioned. The horizontal jaw relation/
centric relation was recorded by guiding mandible to most
anteriorsuperior position in glenoid fossa bimanually / guiding by
touching the tongue in the soft palate and swallowing and occluding,
all these movement was made easier by demonstrating using
s videos and sign language (Figure 2o to 2s).
Followed by teeth arrangement (Ruthinium Dental, Acryrock) in
Class I occlusion relation and the try-in. During try-in interpreter
played a major role by reciprocating phonetics used to evaluate
closest speaking space, freeway space and to evaluate anteroposterior
and vertical overlap relation of anterior etc. by lip reading(
Figure 3). Then evaluated for any discomfort or pain via sign
language and patient satisfaction with the appearance was also
assessed through facial expression and thumbs up/down signs
(Figure 2t, 2u, 2v).
After try-in maxillary and mandibular dentures were acrylized using
heat cure PMMA resin (Dentsply-Lucitone) and denture insertion
was done.
During insertion appointment, the denture is inserted and
checked for the comfort and fit of the complete dentures by various
movements of oral musculature that were displayed on the
laptop screen and by the sign languages (Figure 4h). Then checked
for pressure points and intaglio surface irregularities, this was also
evaluated with the help her facial expression and sign language
indicative of discomfort/ pain. Patient satisfaction on adaptation
and function of denture was evaluated by using signs of thumbs
up / thumbs down and by facial expression and gestures. (Figure
2u, 2v) .post insertion instructions given using complete denture
models ( Figure 4k, 4l).
Patient was then recalled after 24 hours,1week, 1 month intervals
and 3 months. Patient was highly satisfied with the denture.
Figure 2. Instructions to deaf and mute patient using sign languages during complete denture fabrication.
Figure 3. Interpreter (bystander) aiding in lip-reading of words like ‘emma’, ‘om’, ‘m’ for recording vertical dimension at rest.
Figure 4. Steps in complete denture fabrication and complete denture models used to give post-insertion instructions.
Table 3. Grades of hearing impairment as recommended by the Global Burden of Disease Expert Group on Hearing Loss- 2010 [2].
Discussion
According to the data provided by World Health Organization
(WHO), the prevalence of hearing loss amongst individuals in
India is around 6.3 % (63 million individuals suffering from significant
hearing loss).[1] The prevalence of adult-onset deafness
in India is 7.6 % and childhood onset is about 2 %. more than 90
%of hearing loss is Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) caused
by damage to the structures of inner ear or auditory nerve.[14]
Whatever be the type or cause of hearing loss and associated
speech impairment , the diagnosis and intervention at right time
can resolve the problem to a great extent, if not it can impair the
social , and mental well-being of the individual creating a stigma
from society. Hence when such individuals approach the dental or
medical practitioners seeking treatment, communicating in their
preferred mode is always beneficial to both the patient as well as
to the practitioner. Hence it is the responsibility of a practitioner
to learn those skills of communication.
Communication modes like:
• Writing should be the first alternative opted when normal conversation
is impaired. For illiterate it is difficult to understand
Standard English or even their language in written form. In this
case, patient has pre-lingual hearing loss and patient was also illiterate,
hence excluded. At same time this mode is slow, ponderous,
and frustrating. Hence require an interpreter or use of other
method to convey it.[13]
• Speech reading/ lip reading varies in individual based on their
knowledge in standard English or in their language. Hence a combination
of speech reading , visual cues as depicted in this case
report can be opted along with amplification if required.[13]
• Visual language like finger spelling and manual English (grammar
to form sentence), same problem arises where the individual
should be trained properly for expressing each letter and grammatical
structures using hand. These are usually taught in special schools.[13]
• Visual sign language is the most comfortable and easily conveyed
form of expressing vocabularies/ concepts in medical or
dental practice. Doesn't require any special training, even a stranger
can communicate easily with a deaf and mute individual. A
good rapport with patient can be achieved with this alone, without
any interpreter assistance or other aids. [13, 15, 16]
• Visual aids like videos as in this case report, models, diagrams,
charts, etc. adds to the easy understanding and reciprocating the
required functional movements easily during the procedure, also
it can reduce the anxiety if patient is educated with these aids
priorly. [13, 15, 17]
A study conducted by Gupta L et al in 2018 on evaluation of
various visual methods like video and photographs to enhance
the skills between dental care providers and speech and hearing
impaired have revealed that retentiveness of the instruction given
through these mediums lasted upto 1 month and gave around
80% correct response when compared to those groups where no
medium like these were used.[15]
• Above all an interpreter , the bystander in the discussed case
also plays an essential role when illustrating medical procedure or
terminology or while taking consent or when time constraints exists
where slow or inaccurate communication cannot be preferred.
[13]
Among these different methods used visual aids and sign language
efficiently conveyed all necessary commands required during the
procedure and reciprocation of the same by patient. Along with
these interpreter and lip reading technique enhanced the outcome
especially during procedure where phonetics is opted. During the
combination of visual aids like videos and sign language the patient
responses were better throughout the procedure compared
to other techniques.
Conclusion
A prosthodontist should be prudent enough to select right communication
method to develop a rapport and to give necessary information
to deaf and mute patients while treating them. This will
make them feel more comfortable and confident while communicating
and in-turn they will reciprocate all the necessary movements
required for fabrication of the prosthesis. Especially in this
COVID pandemic time it’s difficult to work without PPE , hence
communication with deaf and mute patients via facial expression
by practitioner doesn’t play much role. At the same time movements
of jaws or oral structures cannot be demonstrated by the
practitioners by using all these equipments. Even though visual
aids (video) and sign language are superior, it is always beneficial
to use combination of various methods like visual languages (sign
language), visual aids like video, photographs, charts, models etc.,
postural movements, lip reading, writing techniques and an interpreter
(if condition demands) to communicate with patient for
making the treatment successful. This not only save the time but
also even prevent cross infections & exposure to infection in this
present scenario.
References
-
[1]. Hearing loss and deafness: WHO 2021.
[2]. Hearing and speech impairement resources:
[3]. Hearing impairment:
[4]. Olusanya BO, Davis AC, Hoffman HJ. Hearing loss grades and the International classification of functioning, disability and health. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2019 Oct 1;97(10):725.
[5]. Alberti PW. The anatomy and physiology of the ear and hearing. Occupational exposure to noise: Evaluation, prevention, and control. 2001:53-62.
[6]. Coelho AC, Medved DM, Brasolotto AG. Hearing loss and the voice. An update on hearing loss. 2015 Dec 2:103-28.
[7]. Hall JE, AC G. Guyton and Hall textbook of medical physiology. Korea: Bupmoon Education. 2017.
[8]. Barrett KE, Boitano S, Barman SM, Brooks HL. Ganong’s review of medical physiology. McGraw- Hill Rducation- Europe.2018.
[9]. Chaurasia BD.Human anatomy. CBS Publisher.2004.
[10]. Classification of speech disorders.
[11]. Hearing Loss Treatment and Intervention Services: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2020.
[12]. Hearing loss in children: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities June 2020.
[13]. Brown WS. Communicating With Hearing-Impaired Patients. Western Journal of Medicine. 1977 Aug;127(2):164.
[14]. Chakrabarti S, Ghosh N. Prevalence of severe and profound sensorineural hearing loss in school children in West Bengal, India. Indian Journal of Otolaryngology and Head & Neck Surgery.2019; 71(2):1099-106.
[15]. Gupta L, Jain P, Mora LN, Mujho T.Evaluation of different visual method used, to enhance communication skills between dental care providers and speech and hearing impaired patients. Indian Journal of Dental Research. 2018;29(4):418.
[16]. Jain S, Duggi V, Avinash A, Dubey A, Fouzdar S, Sagar MK.Restoring the voids of voices by signs and gestures, in dentistry: A cross-sectional study. Journal of Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry. 2017;35(2):115.
[17]. Sakpal OS, Joshi S, Gaikwad A, Sanyal P. Achieving Success in the Treatment of Complete Denture in a Hearing-Impaired Patient during Covid-19 Pandemic Using Visual Aids--A Case Report. Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences.2021;10(5):312-6.