An Innovative Technique in Anatomy Pedagogy: The Flexagon as a Model of Gastrulation in Embryology
Karen Kirkness1*, John Sharkey2, Joanne Avison3
1 Hull York Medical School, Health Professions Education Unit (HPEU), University of Chester, UK.
2 Irish College of Osteopathic Medicine (ICOM) 15-16a St Joseph’s Parade, Dorset St, Dublin DO7 F6RC, Ireland.
3 National Training Centre (NTC) 15-16a St Joseph’s Parade, Dorset St, Dublin, Do7 F6RC, Ireland.
*Corresponding Author
Karen Kirkness,
Hull York Medical School, Health ProfessionsEducationUnit (HPEU), University of Chester, UK.
E-mail: hykk9@hyms.ac.uk
Received: September 21, 2021; Accepted: October 19, 2021; Published: October 20, 2021
Citation: Karen Kirkness, John Sharkey, Joanne Avison. An Innovative Technique in Anatomy Pedagogy: The Flexagon as a Model of Gastrulation in Embryology. Int J Anat Appl Physiol. 2021;7(5):209-210. dx.doi.org/10.19070/2572-7451-2100040
Copyright: Karen Kirkness@2021. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Abstract
Research confirms anatomy is considered the corner stone subject within the medical curriculum and in clinical procedures
ensuring safe medical practice by surgeons, doctors and a diverse range of medical specialists. Anatomists agree that understanding
embryology is essential for gaining a comprehensive understanding of anatomy providing the necessary, essential,
context to ensure accurate diagnosis and treatment of patients. These two widely agreed opinions seem to be at odds with the
reduced time and resources devoted to anatomy and embryology within medical education in the United Kingdom and elsewhere.
The objective of this short paper is to promote learning activities that will inspire anatomy educators to delve deeper
into medical embryology and help make important concepts such as invagination more understandable through kinaesthetic
experience. Construction of an innovative technique for teaching anatomy generally and gastrulation specifically is proposed.
Our proposed learning activity points to the need for studies looking at how learners respond to acquiring knowledge this way.
Whether learners perform better upon assessment because of this activity could be examined through a pre/post-test study.
Pedagogical strategies that engage the student while requiring active participation on their part has been demonstrated to be
an effective learning tool when teaching anatomy. Embryonic morphogenesis involves the process of gastrulation occurring at
the third week of human development. A 3-dimensioanlity of gastrulation involves the transformation of a one-dimensional
blastula (a single plane of epithelial cells) into a multidimensional, multi-planar structure referred to as the gastrula. Human
embryos are triploblastic organisms displaying multidimensional embryonic cell planes identified as ectoderm, mesoderm,
and endoderm.
A lessor known and under-appreciated role of gastrulation is the establishment of a tensegrity based architecture informing
emerging organ formation and a multidimensional, biomolecular chiral based body-plan predicated upon a north-south (cranial/
caudal) axis with dorsal/ventral and selective right and left symmetry. This proposed innovative teaching technique includes
the architectural first principles of tensegrity during gastrulation making these difficult concepts easier to comprehend. From
a pedagogical point of view gastrulation has proven to be a most difficult concept for anatomists to teach and for students to
grasp. Research demonstrates the importance concerning knowledge of medical embryology for the anatomist and medical
student alike. To help solve this problem this short paper provides a novel, yet fun approach, to teaching complicated, vital,
underpinning aspects of embryogenesis essential for undergraduate medical students.
2.Introduction
3.Conclusion
4.References
Keywords
Embryology; Pedagogy; Gastrulation; Morphogenesis; Tensegrity.
Introduction
"It is not birth, marriage, or death, but gastrulation, which is truly the most
important time in your life."
Lewis Wolpert (1986)
Research confirms that anatomy is considered to be the corner
stone subject within the medical curriculum and in clinical procedures
to ensure safe medical practice by surgeons, doctors and a
wide diverse range of medical specialists [1-3]. Anatomists would
agree that understanding embryology is essential for gaining a comprehensive understanding of anatomy and teratology [4].
Alarmingly, the overall continuing decline in anatomy and embryology
hours in medical schools is well documented [5]. Teaching
anatomy is an innate challenge and anatomy educators view
embryology as notoriously hard to teach and to learn while the
challenging subject matter can become even more difficult with
the reduction in emphasis as a subject.Medical students have fewer
hours to learn anatomy, and many see little point in learning
embryology other than to pass exam questions [6]. The authors
address this unfortunate decline in interest in embryology using a
novel learning technique aimedat making the concept more accessible
while inspiring greater interest in embryology as a fascinating
subject that serves to illuminate anatomical knowledge as part of
long-term clinical professionalism and medical related competencies
[7].
Knowledge of anatomy has been identified as critical within the
operating room [1].
The result is a multi-dimensional folded paper embryo that anatomists
can interact with and use to reinforce the process of invagination/
enfolding during gastrulation (Fig 1). The origami action
of folding the paper reinforces the concept of morphological
constraints arising from internal mechanical circumstances of biologic
geometry and force transmission [8]. Research has shown
that by introducing a 3-Dimensional aspect to both the visual and
kinaesthtic learning a greatervisuospatial appreciation is gained
supporting a broader understanding of anatomy and embryology
[9]. A lessor known and under-appreciated role of gastrulation
is the establishment of a tensegrity based architecture informing
emerging organ formation and a multidimensional, biomolecular
chiral based body-plan predicated upon a north-south (cranial/
caudal) axis with dorsal/ventral and selective right and left symmetry
[10]. The 3D hexaflexagon,representing a multi-dimensional,
folded, paper embryo (Fig 1) is offered as the ideal teaching
tool to support anatomy educators when explaining the mechanical
forces of morphogenesis and embryological development.
Figure 1 (a, b, c, d, e). From a single piece of paper students are instructed in the folding technique that results in a 3D hexaflexagon representing a multi-dimensional, folded, paper embryo. The activity, while being fun, is informative providing both a kinaesthetic and visual experience of several important processes including invagination, blastula folding and 3-dimentionality.
Figure 2. Adding colours to the constructed hexaflexagon allows for a more pronounced visual experience.
Conclusion
As medical and clinical training pathways evolve student learning
needs and their educational preferences need also to evolve.
The aim of this paper is to propose that a greater understanding
of the stages of embryonic folding can be achieved through
folding one’s own origami flexagon, or 3D hexaflexagon (aka
“kaleidocycle”) (Fig 2).A better understanding of embryology in
the wider context of anatomy will better serve the medical student.
Anatomy educators are crutial members of all medial teaching
faculties ensuring under-graduate and post-graduate medical
students gain an anatomically accurate and detailed education
required to operate in a patient focused safe, appropriate and effective
manner. We trust that our proposal will help anatomy educators
move one step closer in achieving that goal.
References
- Aziz N, Mansor O. The role of anatomists and surgeons in clinical anatomy instruction inside and outside the operating room. Malays J Med Sci. 2006 Jan;13(1):76-7.Pubmed PMID: 22589596.
- Sbayeh A, Qaedi Choo MA, Quane KA, Finucane P, McGrath D, O'Flynn S, et al. Relevance of anatomy to medical education and clinical practice: perspectives of medical students, clinicians, and educators. Perspect Med Educ. 2016 Dec;5(6):338-346.Pubmed PMID: 27785729.
- Sawant SP, Rizvi S. Role of clinical anatomy in first MBBS curriculum. MOJ Anat Physiol. 2017;3(1):1-5.
- Varga I. EMBRYOLOGY TEACHING: AN OFTEN-NEGLECTED PART OF THE MEDICAL CURRICULUM. Revista Argentina de Anatomía Clínica. 2017;9(2):47-51.
- Heylings DJ. Anatomy 1999–2000: The curriculum, who teaches it and how?. Med. Educ. 2002 Aug;36(8):702-10.
- McKeown PP, Heylings DJ, Stevenson M, McKelvey KJ, Nixon JR, R Mc- Cluskey D. The impact of curricular change on medical students' knowledge of anatomy. Med. Educ. 2003 Nov;37(11):954-61.
- Lachman N, Pawlina W. Integrating professionalism in early medical education: the theory and application of reflective practice in the anatomy curriculum. Clin Anat. 2006 Jul;19(5):456-60.Pubmed PMID: 16683241.
- Alberch P. The logic of monsters: evidence for internal constraint in development and evolution. Geobios. 1989 Jan 1;22:21-57.
- Hernandez JE, Vasan N, Huff S, Melovitz-Vasan C. Learning Styles/Preferences Among Medical Students: Kinesthetic Learner's Multimodal Approach to Learning Anatomy. Med Sci Educ. 2020 Aug 27;30(4):1633-1638.Pubmed PMID: 34457831.
- Mammoto T, Ingber DE. Mechanical control of tissue and organ development. Dev. 2010 May 1;137(9):1407-20.